I recommend minor revision

Author: gyen

August undefined, 2024

WebResponse: A minor revision often implies that there are a limited number of changes that are needed to improve the manuscript for publication. Depending on the extent of the minor revision, the editor may decide not to send it out for re-review. A major revision often requires more substantive changes prior to being appropriate for publication. WebJan 8, 2014 · First, if you agree with the reviewer, you should do exactly what the reviewer ask you to do, and mention that you have done it. Then the reviewer should be happy. Second, you can disagree with the reviewer and explain why you disagree. In this case, you only need to explain why you disagree. But you need to explain well why.

BG - Peer review - Reviews and syntheses: Present, past, and …

WebIf recommending revision, state specific changes you feel need to be made. The author can then reply to each point in turn. Some journals offer the option to recommend rejection … WebIt is very possible to get a minor revision as a first decision, and then major revision as second decision, and finally a rejection. This can be heart-breaking to authors. fitbit 2 download

Journal Said “Major Revisions” Needed? Here’s What to Do

WebReviewer #I recommended publication; Reviewer #2 suggested 5 or 6 major modifications, any one of which would require essentially the researching and writing of another paper, and 2 or 3 years of ... WebPerform any additional experiments or analyses the reviewers recommend (unless you feel that they would not make your paper better; if so, please provide sufficient explanation as to why you believe this to be the case in your response letter). Provide a polite and scientific rebuttal to any points or comments you disagree with. WebMinor revisions and major revisions are the two most common editorial decisions after peer review. A decision of minor revisions means your work will likely not be going back to the original peer reviewers for another round of comments. This is actually a policy for many journals. Do the revisions and resubmit. fitbit 2 charger cable

Step by Step Guide to Reviewing a Manuscript Wiley

What does a ‘revisions required’ editorial decision really …

WebMinor revision. Your article has a very good chance of being accepted for publication, but the reviewers have requested minor amendments to be made. These changes can usually … fitbit 2 displays wrong timeWebMinor issues are still important but typically will not affect the overall conclusions of the manuscript. Here are some examples of what would might go in the “minor” category: Missing references (but depending on what is missing, this could also be a major issue) Technical clarifications (e.g., the authors should clarify how a reagent works) canfield high school boys basketball schedule

"WebJul 13, 2024 · After submitting major revision, I got minor revision with only one comment from editor, while one reviewer accepted it (it was not sent to second reviewer). I … " - I recommend minor revision

I recommend minor revision

Is it possible to get major revision after minor revision? Any ideas …

WebMinor revisions - the best you can hope for after the first round of review Major revisions - the decision we received in this case Reject – clearly, the one you want to avoid Editors … WebThe first read-through is a skim-read. It will help you form an initial impression of the paper and get a sense of whether your eventual recommendation will be to accept or reject the paper. First Read Considerations Keep a pen and paper handy when skim-reading.

Did you know?

Webrecommend this manuscript to be published with a minor revision. • Response: The comments and suggestionsfrom the referee#1 are greatly appreciated. All technical … WebI recommend you try the meatballs. I will be recommending the meatballs tonight. Both of these examples are correct. However, “I recommend” here means we’re recommending …

WebMinor revision. The paper will be ready for publication after light revisions. Please list the revisions you would recommend the author makes. Major revision. The paper needs substantial changes such as expanded data analysis, widening of the literature review, or rewriting sections of the text. Reject. The paper isn’t suitable for ... WebApr 9, 2024 · The Editorial Office is waiting for your revised manuscript. As an author, this manuscript status means that it’s time to review your manuscript and edit it using the comments provided. We expect to receive revisions within 5 days (for minor revisions) or within 10 days (for major revisions). This is inclusive of weekends and holidays.

WebApr 13, 2024 · Accept with minor revisions ... Make the recommended changes and resubmit to the same journal: This option could well be your top choice if you are keen to publish in a particular journal and if the editor has indicated that they will accept your paper if revisions are made. If the editor has issued an outright rejection and does not wish to ... WebRecommend Immediate-Reject If you feel the manuscript is 1) out of the scope of TMI, or 2) the quality is too low to meet TMI standards, or 3) the novelty of the work is insignificant, or 4) just “good” instead of “exceptional” or “excellent”, you are encouraged to recommend an immediate reject without pursuing the full review process.

WebApr 16, 2024 · My review article received a minor revision with one of the comments as follows: “The advantages, disadvantages, and synergy of each strategy need to be …

WebAccepted with minor revisions . Minor revisions are recommended for manuscripts which make a clear and sound contribution, but require a few small changes to ensure it is fully fit for publication. This usually includes textual changes based on clarification of minor points or sentences, abbreviations, minor revision to figures for clarity. Etc. canfield high school craft showWebNo, minor revision doesn't mean accepted with minor revisions. Strictly speaking, for truly minor revisions, it's possible that the editor accepts your paper and leaves you to make the remaining changes during proofs. Since the editor didn't do this, it's still possible your … fitbit 2 charge reviewWebAccept with Minor Revision This is for manuscripts with minor issues and you don’t need to see the revision before the manuscript is accepted. The AE will check if all the comments are addressed. Sample reviewer comments: “ This paper proposes a novel approach towards solving the reconstruction problem of motion corrupted fetal MRI. canfield highWebIn other words, if you receive such a revised manuscript for review, you should make either a recommendation to accept (possibly with a minor revision) or reject with no further … canfield high school craft show 2022WebJan 9, 2024 · Often the peer review process progresses smoothly through the steps: A new manuscript is submitted; appropriate reviewers are identified, invited and promptly accept; … canfield high school christmas craft showWebApr 15, 2024 · Six minor proposals were rejected, including forcing large companies to publish how many over-55s they employ, and the creation of a special contract for older workers. The appearance of the text in France's Official Journal -- the gazette of record -- means it has now been enacted into law. "The Social Security Code is thus amended. canfield high school baseballWebRelated to Response times for Exams requiring Sonographer review. Log Reviews All systems processing and/or storing PHI COUNTY discloses to 11 CONTRACTOR or CONTRACTOR creates, receives, maintains, or transmits on behalf of COUNTY 12 must have a routine procedure in place to review system logs for unauthorized access.. Peer Review … canfield high school football 2022